The Punchline reads the press you don’t get to. Every day we go through thousands of newspapers, magazines and journals in more than 30 languages. Software does the first reading. Our editors keep what is worth repeating at dinner.

Tell us the occasion and we build you a brief for it. Or browse. Vignettes follow one development as it turns up in several countries at once. Question Marks take an idea most people accept and set out the case for and against. The Newsletter brings the day’s selection every evening, free of charge.

THE PUNCHLINE

Your guide to shining at dinner parties

Question Mark · 02

Are elected leaders still answerable to voters when they work through private companies?

Reading time · 3 min

Brazil’s election can change mining rules for a company whose shareholder is the United States government.

Repórter Brasil·BRAZIL | 2026
  • This September, USA Rare Earth, a US mining company, listed Brazil’s election as a risk to its Brazilian business.
  • President Trump’s government funds mining companies to reduce dependence on China for minerals used in motors and weapons.
  • The buyer acquired Brazil’s only operating rare-earth mine after Washington announced a $1.6 billion investment and became a shareholder.
  • President Lula signed a minerals law allowing Brazil’s government to review foreign ownership and international contracts.
In the article

100% of the mine’s production of four magnetic rare earths is committed to a company funded by the US government and private investors.

Diego Junqueira, Repórter Brasil journalist, September 202601
Elsewhere3
Britain / Persia1914

Britain took 51% of the Anglo-Persian Oil Company in 1914 to secure fuel for its navy. The company’s managers had spent a year persuading a reluctant government to buy them.

Michael Sander, political economist, New Political Economy, 201904
Britain / India1600–1800s

England’s Crown authorised the trading firm East India Company to run colonies. By the late eighteenth century it collected Indian taxes and ran courts. Its London headquarters were five windows wide.

William Dalrymple, historian of the East India Company, The New York Times, August 202605
Germany2024

Germany barred Russian gas tankers from unloading at its terminals. Its state-owned gas company, SEFE, bought Russian supplies through French and Belgian ports; imports entering through Belgium were counted as Belgian gas.

Igor Sevenard, politics researcher, German Politics, August 202606
And it's not just them·2 more
SWEDEN | 2026

1Should the state still answer for a service it has handed over to private companies?

  • This September, Swedish television tested job coaches by sending a reporter posing as a controlling husband.
  • Sweden’s employment agency pays these private companies to help unemployed people find jobs.
  • The reporter wanted his wife excused from activities and kept away from work and other men.
  • One coach promised that she could stay home for life.
In the article

33 of 72 offices tested were willing to help the reporter with his plan.

SVT, Sweden’s public television broadcaster, undercover test reported by Leonidas Aretakis in Flamman, September 202603
Elsewhere3
Indiana2006–2014

In 2006, Indiana sold a 157-mile stretch of I-90 to a Spanish and Australian consortium for $3.8 billion. The firms raised tolls from $4.65 to $8.00, pushing truckers onto narrow side roads that got chewed up—yet noncompete clauses in the sale barred the state from improving those roads. In 2014 the consortium declared bankruptcy.

The New Republic, book review by journalist Robin Kaiser-Schatzlein, April 202211
Toronto2018–2020

A Toronto snow contractor billed the city for ploughing until 6 a.m. The truck’s GPS showed it had returned to the yard at 11:37 the previous night.

Beverly Romeo-Beehler, Toronto’s auditor general, October 202007
Chicago2018

Chicago paid Waste Management, a waste company, to collect recycling even when it tagged bins as contaminated and left them behind. The company earned another fee when city crews dumped their contents in its landfill.

Madison Hopkins, Better Government Association investigative reporter, October 201810
EUROPE | 2026

2Should a country depend on another government's companies to hold its citizens' data?

  • In January 2026, the European Parliament called for Europe to reduce its dependence on foreign technology suppliers.
  • American technology suppliers answer to US law even when they store their customers’ data in Europe.
  • French senators asked Microsoft, the US software company, whether it could give US authorities French citizens’ data without France’s consent.
  • Its French legal director could not guarantee otherwise at the June 2025 hearing.
In the article

Weaponized interdependence: a government pressures other countries through the financial or digital networks they depend on.

współzależności jako broni

Political scientists Henry Farrell and Abraham Newman’s term, explained by Tomasz S. Markiewka, September 202602
Elsewhere3
London1960s

The first depositor in London's Eurodollar market was, of all governments, the Soviet Union. It wanted interest on its dollars but refused to hold them in American banks, where the US government could confiscate or freeze the deposits. Keeping the money offshore put it beyond Washington's legal reach.

The New York Review of Books, review essay by historian Quinn Slobodian, May 202412
Britain / United States2025

Apple, the technology company, challenged a British order to open its encrypted cloud storage to authorities. America’s intelligence chief said the demand would violate Americans’ rights. A tribunal refused to keep the case’s existence secret.

Associated Press, reporting the Investigatory Powers Tribunal’s ruling, 7 April 202508
Iceland / United States2011

An American judge allowed investigators to obtain an Icelandic parliamentarian’s private records from Twitter, the social network. She learned of the demand because Twitter sought permission to notify customers. She could not learn which other companies had received orders.

Civil-liberties groups ACLU and EFF, representing the Icelandic parliamentarian, 201109
Sources12 works and reports · 12 outbound linksopen
  1. Source1

    Mineradora dos EUA de terras raras no Brasil vê 'risco’ em eleições

    Diego Junqueira · 2026-09-23

    Read original source
  2. Source2

    Na łasce Ameryki. A gdyby Trump kazał wyłączyć nam Gmaila?

    Tomasz S. Markiewka · 2026-09-24

    Read original source
  3. Source3

    När Centerpartiet råkade införa nyliberal sharia

    Leonidas Aretakis · 2026-09-10

    Read original source
  4. Source4

    Why Companies Bring the State Back In. The Voluntary Self-Nationalisation of the Anglo-Persian Oil Company and the Rise of ‘Governance by Government’

    Michael Sander, 11 September 2019

    Read original source
  5. Source5

    What It Took to Dismantle the Most Powerful Company in the World

    William Dalrymple, 2026-08-28

    Read original source
  6. Source6

    Germany After the Zeitenwende : Strategic Temporising as a Foreign Policy Implementation Failure

    Igor Sevenard, 2026-08-27

    Read original source
  7. Source7

    Audit of Winter Road Maintenance Program — Phase One

    Beverly Romeo-Beehler · 14 October 2020

    Read original source
  8. Source8

    UK court reveals Apple’s fight against government order for backdoor access to encrypted cloud data

    Associated Press, reporting the Investigatory Powers Tribunal’s ruling, 7 April 2025

    Read original source
  9. Source9

    ACLU And EFF Appeal Ruling In Case Challenging Government Attempt To Obtain Private Data

    ACLU and Electronic Frontier Foundation, lawyers for the Icelandic parliamentarian, 2011

    Read original source
  10. Source10

    Private Chicago city hauler is diverting tons of recyclables to its landfills

    Madison Hopkins · 12 October 2018

    Read original source
  11. Source11

    Don’t Privatize Water

    Robin Kaiser-Schatzlein · 2022-04-10

    Read original source
  12. Source12

    Safe Havens

    Quinn Slobodian · 2024-05-17

    Read original source