Can you teach someone a skill and still control its use?
Reading time · 3 min
Workers sell demonstrations of their chores to robot developers who choose what the machines will learn.
- This year, a Nigerian graduate began filming household chores for Atlas Capture, an app that pays for training videos.
- Robot developers buy first-person footage to teach machines how people move and handle objects.
- Atlas Capture can reject footage without payment when the recorder’s hands leave the frame.
- An AI investor unsuccessfully proposed a jointly owned company that would train AI with union members’ recordings.
US$50 for 17 hours of video: a Nigerian graduate’s first week filming chores for Atlas Capture.
In Saadi’s Gulistan, a wrestler teaches his favourite pupil 359 of his 360 tricks. The pupil boasts that he equals his teacher, then loses their bout to the withheld trick.
A French chef watched a former employee demonstrate his recipe on television without crediting him. He demanded credit in a letter and sent copies to fellow chefs.
A former English mill apprentice memorised the machinery and secretly left for America in 1789, despite Britain’s ban on textile workers sharing technical information or emigrating. His Rhode Island mill was running by the end of 1790.
1Can sharing your tricks give you more say at work?
- Fiat workers in 1960s Turin kept quiet about the safety tricks missing from the carmaker’s instructions.
- Unions relied on company doctors and bargained for extra pay for hazardous work.
- A factory doctor asked workers to teach an imaginary replacement every trick needed to pass unnoticed.
- Their findings entered union agreements and helped inform the 1978 law creating Italy’s national health service.
“By 1994, Oddone could no longer tell whether his generation’s victories were still alive.”
År 1994 kunde Oddone inte längre avgöra om hans generations segrar fortfarande levde.
Scandinavian newspaper workers used cardboard computers to show designers how their jobs worked. Their union helped develop a pilot tool used at Aftonbladet, a Swedish newspaper.
Aircraft-parts workers at Lucas Aerospace pooled their skills to propose 150 products, including wind turbines. Managers rejected the plan. The workers also built a bus that ran on roads and rails.
General Electric, an aircraft-engine maker, tried to cut workers’ wages with automated machine tools. Workers pooled knowledge of the machines and changing pay rates. Under strike pressure, the company agreed to review its rates.
2Does sharing a new technique give everyone the right to use it?
- Two Cambridge scientists published their method for making identical antibodies in August 1975.
- Patent holders can restrict who uses an invention. These scientists obtained no patent for their technique.
- A British research official had alerted the government’s patenting agency before publication.
- The agency replied that it saw no immediate commercial use after the scientists had already published their method.
More than a year passed before Britain’s patenting agency replied, in October 1976.
Inventor Benjamin Franklin published stove instructions and declined a patent. A London ironmonger copied the pamphlet, altered the stove and patented it. Franklin said the changes made it work worse.
France released inventor Louis Daguerre’s photographic process as a gift to the world. An agent also patented the process in England on his behalf.
NeXT, a computer company, wanted to distribute an extension to freely shared software while keeping its code closed. The original developers’ lawyer said their licence forbade this. NeXT released the code.
Sources12 works and reports · 11 outbound linksopenclose
- Source1
Basic Instincts
Joe Castaldo, 2026-10-10
- Source2
- Source3
- Source4
- Source5
- Source6
Digital worker inquiry and the critical potential of participatory worker data science for on-demand platform workers
Cailean Gallagher, Karen Gregory, Boyan Karabaliev, 2025
Read original source - Source7
- Source8
- Source9
Norms-based intellectual property systems: the case of French chefs
Emmanuelle Fauchart, Eric von Hippel, 2006-01-30
Read original source - Source10
Free Software, Free Society: Selected Essays of Richard M. Stallman
Richard M. Stallman, 2015
Read original source - Source11
- Source12
