If a government can't do without a private company, who's really in charge?
Reading time · 3 min
Brazil’s electoral court pays communications firm Hughes to transmit remote election results over Elon Musk’s Starlink network, but Starlink has no direct contract requiring it to keep the court connected.
- For the 2026 election, Brazil's electoral court paid Hughes, a satellite firm, about R$8 million to link remote polling sites.
- Results from remote sites in 13 states travel via Starlink, Elon Musk's satellite network, which Hughes relies on.
- The court required no direct commitment from Starlink, saying that could limit competition, so only Hughes answers for failures.
- The court rejected a backup satellite technology, saying the extra cost could make the project unaffordable.
“The voting machines operate offline, and the results reports are digitally signed and protected by encryption.”
As urnas funcionam isoladas da internet, e os boletins são assinados digitalmente e protegidos por criptografia.
Britain’s tax-and-benefits website went down with the online game Fortnite during an Amazon cloud outage in October 2025. Users saw an error message until Amazon restored service.
Kenya agreed to a ten-year deal for contractor Safaricom to host its health information system. During the contract, the government owns none of the software rights and cannot switch suppliers after five years.
Britain abandoned its centrally run contact-tracing app after it detected only 4% of iPhones in an Isle of Wight test. The health secretary said Apple would not change its phone software. Ministers adopted the Apple–Google design.
1Can a government expect help without telling businesses what to do?
- Britain is preparing a campaign urging households to stockpile food and water for emergencies in 2026.
- Food businesses supply the country, but officials have not shared the government’s food-crisis plan with them.
- The industry has not been invited to government crisis exercises.
- Local emergency groups have not been told what to do when supermarket shelves are empty.
“The National Audit Office has observed, drily, that this means the “plans may not work in practice”.”
Soviet officials classified new instructions for handling secret documents as top secret. Clerks cleared only for secret material could not read the rules governing their own work; making extracts was forbidden too.
Young women at Oak Ridge were taught to keep instrument needles within a narrow range without being told they were separating uranium for an atomic bomb. In a contest, they outperformed the physicists who understood the machines.
Moscow’s Polytechnic Museum asked contractors to design its exhibitions without telling them how much money they could spend. One contractor also had to negotiate each month over who would pay his own firm.
2Does a government answer to its landlord?
- An Italian court faces eviction on 29 December 2026 after government officials rejected its landlord’s proposed rent.
- Italy sold 396 public buildings to a private property fund in 2004 and rented them back.
- When leases expired, government offices stayed without renewed contracts, paying the previous rent as compensation.
- The government negotiated an option to buy back twenty buildings from the fund.
15% off the rent: Italy’s 2024 budget law let parties who had terminated leases revive them at a reduced rent.
Britain sold about 55,000 military family homes for £1.66 billion in 1996, then rented homes back on 200-year leases. In 2025 it paid £5.99 billion to buy back 36,347 homes.
Arizona sold its capitol and other buildings during the Great Recession, raising $700 million, then leased them back. A decade later, the state planned to borrow money to buy the capitol back.
The New York Times sold part of its headquarters for $225 million in 2009 to pay debts, then leased it back. The rent started at $24 million a year; buying it back after ten years would cost $250 million.
Sources12 works and reports · 12 outbound linksopenclose
- Source1
On the role of Law in African health data futures
Sharifah Sekalala, Sonali Silva, 2026-10-05
Read original source - Source2
Why Digital Sovereignty Matters
Cecilia Rikap and Paolo Gerbaudo, Tribune, 10 November 2025
Read original source - Source3
UK abandons contact-tracing app for Apple and Google model
The Guardian, 18 June 2020
Read original source - Source4
- Source5
Mark Harrison, "Secret Leviathan: Secrecy and State Capacity under Soviet Communism" (Stanford UP, 2023)
Mark Harrison, interviewed by Miranda Melcher
Read original source - Source6
- Source7
- Source8
- Source9
MOD lost billions after selling and leasing back service family homes – National Audit Office
Forces News, military news service, June 2026
Read original source - Source10
- Source11
- Source12
