Isn’t the point of controlling access precisely to take it away?
Reading time · 3 min
SpaceX’s proposed Louisiana base would repeatedly clear nearby waters for safe rocket launches, potentially leaving shrimp crews unable to fish where they have worked for years.
- On Aug. 25, 2026, SpaceX, the rocket company, announced a US$100-billion launch site around Louisiana’s Pecan Island.
- Coastal launches send rockets over open water to reduce danger to people.
- SpaceX says each launch clears everyone within five to eight kilometers of the pad for two hours.
- At SpaceX’s target of over 30 launches a day, shrimpers in slow boats could find the waters all but closed.
US$100 billion to develop 125,000 acres around Pecan Island, SpaceX and Louisiana’s governor announced in August.
Irish fishers told Russia they would keep fishing where its navy planned to fire artillery and launch rockets in February 2022. After appeals from the fishers and Irish government, Russia moved the exercises away from their fishing grounds.
Tech workers paid $27 to reserve a San Francisco soccer field, then tried to remove neighborhood children already playing there. After the confrontation went viral in 2014, the parks department ended adult reservations at Mission Playground.
London councils rent public parks to music events. Figures reported in 2019 showed that full public access to Blackheath, one of London’s largest commons, could be restricted for almost half the year.
1What should a public space have to provide?
- New York advocates are pressing a planned Midtown tower to add public bathrooms to its three public terraces.
- The city gives developers permission for larger buildings in exchange for spaces open to everyone.
- The tower’s developers received extra building rights, but public bathrooms were not required.
- A resident with Crohn’s disease avoids Midtown because reaching the nearest bathroom can take too long.
Only 14 of New York’s roughly 600 privately owned public spaces have bathrooms.
Shanghai gives developers extra floor space for public plazas. Researchers found no free seats in 18 of 42 plazas they studied. A woman standing beside a marble flower bed said it was too hot to sit on in summer and too cold in winter.
Hong Kong made public space a condition of developers’ land leases. Government auditors found one such space reached by climbing 200 steps. An advocate said the leases required entry without requiring easy access.
Britain exempted stately homes from inheritance tax in return for public access. Neighbors did not know they could visit the Duke of Somerset’s home, so a comedian brought coachloads of them and flew a balloon displaying the duke’s phone number.
2Is your home really yours if you cannot use its water?
- A woman in southern Chile fetched buckets from a canal behind her home despite having no right to its water.
- Chile’s 1981 Water Code made water rights tradable separately from land.
- Outside farmers or companies can hold the water rights while nearby residents rely on emergency deliveries.
- A 2022 reform prioritized household water use, but existing entitlements and gaps in pipes and pumps persist.
“It makes me sad and embarrassed having to tell my guests: ‘Please, don’t use too much water’.”
Ghana owned the trees that grew naturally on cocoa farms and could license loggers to cut them. Farmers had to prove a tree was planted to claim it; loggers often ignored the requirement to obtain farmers’ consent.
A Texas family bought a ranch, then an oil company acquired two dozen wells there without involving them. The family owned the surface. The company leased the mineral rights underneath.
A British lord wrote to homeowners claiming rights over their land. These old manorial rights could survive a sale and include hunting or holding fairs. Residents demanded that he surrender them.
Sources12 works and reports · 12 outbound linksopenclose
- Source1
The Restless River journey ends in Louisiana, where SpaceX dreams collide with reality on Earth
Ivan Semeniuk · 2026-10-31
Read original source - Source2
A New Tower Will Have Lots of Public Space but No Public Bathrooms
Winnie Hu, New York Times, October 10, 2026
Read original source - Source3
Everyday water insecurity in decentralized water systems: Emotions, coping, and justice across hydrosocial territories in Southern Chile
Luz Galvis, Àlex Boso, Àlvaro Hofflinger, Lucia Alexandra Popartan · 2026-09-25
Read original source - Source4
Mission Soccer Field Incident Prompts Change in Reservation Policy
October 16, 2014
Read original source - Source5
How a group of Irish fishermen forced the Russian Navy into a U-turn
January 31, 2022
Read original source - Source6
- Source7
How Texas’s Zombie Oil Wells Are Creating an Environmental Disaster Zone
Grist and The Texas Observer, April 15, 2021
Read original source - Source8
Female cocoa farmers challenge Ghanaian tree tenure law
Tropenbos Ghana, account of August 10, 2022 campaign
Read original source - Source9
Lord's land claim for Hatfield and Welwyn Garden City 'not alarming'
BBC News, November 11, 2013
Read original source - Source10
Comic Mark exposes 'tax dodge toffs'
Millie Jenkins, The Independent, November 9, 1997
Read original source - Source11
How public are they? Privately owned public spaces in Shanghai, China
Yiming Wang and Jie Chen, urban researchers, June 18, 2026
Read original source - Source12
How Hong Kong’s developers are abusing public space
Hong Kong Free Press, September 17, 2017
Read original source
