Can trade ever exist without force?
Reading time · 3 min
In Rio neighborhoods controlled by armed gangs, residents must buy essentials through the gangs’ monopolies, and the money helps those gangs seize more neighborhoods.
- In October 2026, gang leaders still ruled Rio favelas where a police raid killed 122 people a year earlier.
- The Comando Vermelho, an armed criminal group, monopolizes essentials such as cooking gas and internet in neighborhoods it controls.
- Its leaders fund new conquests by extorting residents and merchants and selling drugs.
“Drug trafficking today accounts for an ever smaller share of the gangs’ revenue.”
O tráfico de drogas hoje responde por uma fatia cada vez menor da receita das facções.
Al-Shabab, Somalia’s armed Islamist movement, gives truckers a receipt after one road-tax payment, allowing passage through its other checkpoints. It attacks roads outside its control to push drivers onto its routes.
Orange growers in Santa Engracia must buy wooden crates from the Gulf cartel’s designated seller. A crate that previously cost two pesos now costs five.
New York gangsters imposed surcharges on baby artichokes. In December 1935, Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia banned their sale; three days later, the racket was broken and the ban lifted.
1Is buying food a free choice if gathering it is forbidden?
- In 1788, English judges ruled the poor had no legal right to glean leftover harvest grain.
- Gleaning gave some families a year's bread without buying any.
- The judges held that the farmer's soil and seed made the leftovers his.
- Mary Houghton's fine was 35 pounds 5 shillings; her cobbler husband borrowed from his leather supplier to pay.
“Estovers meant gathering wood: a right named in the medieval Great Charters of Liberty alongside grazing rights”
France’s 1827 forest code barred villagers from gathering deadwood and berries. Peasants in Ariège fought forest guards wearing long white shirts and wigs, with darkened faces to avoid recognition.
Colonial officials allowed the Soliga people to collect water and visit shrines in their ancestral forest. Gathering honey or firewood made them forest offenders.
New York parks prohibit picking plants without permission. In 2016 an artist helped build a floating food forest on a barge, where visitors could pick herbs and fruit because waterways were governed differently from parkland.
2Can free trade begin with force?
- Indian Ocean, aboard the Portuguese carrack Santa Catarina. 1603. The Dutch East India Company, a merchant trading company, seized the carrack and its treasure.
- Portugal, backed by the pope, claimed the sole right to trade in these waters.
- Hugo Grotius, a young Dutch jurist, argued the company's case: Dutch merchants had a right to trade there.
- His legal opinion justifying the seizure contained a chapter later famous as Freedom of the Seas.
The Calico Acts prohibited imports of printed cloth from India to protect English manufacturers, before Britain championed free trade.
The American frigate Essex had spent a year capturing British whaling ships when it raised a “Free Trade and Sailors Rights” banner in Valparaíso in 1814. The British ship facing it answered with its own banner defending sailors’ loyalty to king and country.
France’s king rejected Spain and Portugal’s division of the overseas world: “I should very much like to see the clause in Adam’s will that excludes me from a share of the world.” He ordered eight more ships to raid their vessels.
France sent 14 warships to Haiti in 1825 with an order opening its ports to every nation on equal terms. French ships alone would pay half the normal duties.
Sources12 works and reports · 12 outbound linksopenclose
- Source1
Sem novidade no ‘front’ do Complexo do Alemão
Anna Bustamante, Roberta de Souza · 2026-10-28
Read original source - Source2
- Source3
- Source4
- Source5
- Source6
Behold the Baby Artichoke, or, Power to the Punies
Read original source - Source7
- Source8
- Source9
- Source10
- Source11
A Commercial (Neo)colony? The Role of the Merchant Lobby in France’s Recognition of Haitian Independence
Mary D. Lewis, June 20, 2022
Read original source - Source12
