The Punchline reads the press you don’t get to. Every day we go through thousands of newspapers, magazines and journals in more than 30 languages. Software does the first reading. Our editors keep what is worth repeating at dinner.

Tell us the occasion and we build you a brief for it. Or browse. Vignettes follow one development as it turns up in several countries at once. Question Marks take an idea most people accept and set out the case for and against. The Newsletter brings the day’s selection every evening, free of charge.

THE PUNCHLINE

Your guide to shining at dinner parties

Question Mark · 10

Can we reward good work without quantifying it?

Reading time · 3 min

Artificial intelligence researchers promise to judge graduate applicants by how well they understand their work and say a long list of weak papers can hurt their chances of admission.

學人Scholar·CHINA AND INTERNATIONAL SIGNATORIES | 2026
  • In October 2026, over a hundred artificial intelligence researchers pledged to stop screening graduate applicants by publication count.
  • The signatories say students rush to publish because classmates' growing paper lists make them fear falling behind.
  • They promise to question applicants closely about their research decisions and failures.
  • They warn that producing many weak papers quickly can count against an applicant.
In the article

“One paper that you thoroughly understand is far more convincing than ten papers that merely bear your name.”

一篇被你吃透的论文,远比十篇你只挂了名字的论文更有说服力。

AI researchers signing the slow research pledge, 學人Scholar, October 202601
Elsewhere3
Massachusetts, United States1966–1970

Hampshire College’s founders said a student could earn a degree without taking any courses. Faculty assessed substantial projects, such as plays or books of poems, and wrote evaluations instead of giving grades.

Hannah Gais, journalist and Hampshire graduate, The Baffler, August 202605
Düdingen, Switzerland2026

Swiss inspectors grade each dairy’s monthly Gruyère cheese production for quality. A score of 19 out of 20 earns one village cheesemaker about 4,000 francs extra a month. She shares some with her milk farmers.

Hans Gerlach, food writer, Süddeutsche Zeitung, October 202604
Edinburgh, Scotland1980–2013

A physicist at Edinburgh University answered requests for recent publications with “None.” He said the university kept him because his earlier work might win a Nobel Prize. He received it in 2013.

Peter Higgs, Nobel-winning physicist, interviewed by The Guardian, December 201306
And it's not just them·2 more
INDONESIA | 2026

1Does being judged by numbers deter cheating?

  • In Indonesia in 2026, a runner sells customers records of runs they never did.
  • Strava, an exercise tracking app, lets people share their routes and times online.
  • Customers hand over their Strava accounts or GPS devices and agree on a route and distance.
  • The hired runner completes the route for their account.
In the article

A five kilometre run costs the customer at least 200,000 rupiah; each additional kilometre costs another 40,000.

Untuk jarak 5 kilometer, harga yang diberikan mulai dari Rp 200.000 dengan pace 4–8, tergantung permintaan. Apabila lebih dari 5 kilometer, akan dikenai biaya tambahan Rp 40.000 per 1 kilometer.

Caecilia Mediana and Fidelia Fortunaya Hardjosukanto, reporters, Kompas, October 202602
Elsewhere4
United States2020

VIDA, a dating service, paid writers $12 an hour to flirt through customers’ profiles, plus $1.75 per phone number obtained. Customers paid $495 to $1,695 a month.

Current Affairs, Personalities for Sale09
New York2011

A New York student charged up to $2,500 to sit college entrance tests under his clients’ names. One satisfied customer gave him a $1,100 tip.

Alison Stewart, CBS News correspondent, 201208
United States2019

A memoir client asked, “So you think I have a sense of humor, huh?” Her ghostwriter answered, “Well, you’ve got the one I gave you.”

Michel Anteby and Nicholas Occhiuto, sociologists, Stand-in Labor and the Rising Economy of Self, 201907
RomeFirst century CE

A wealthy Roman bought slaves who had memorised the poets and kept them beside his dinner couch to supply quotations. Seneca says the man believed he knew whatever anyone in his household knew.

Seneca, Roman philosopher, Moral Letters to Lucilius, Letter 2710
SUNNYVALE, CALIFORNIA | 1984–2023

2When officials miss their own targets, what's to stop them from lowering the bar?

  • Sunnyvale, California, sets annual targets for city services and publishes the results in its budgets.
  • City department heads could persuade the city manager to change targets as council scrutiny weakened.
  • After missed targets, Sunnyvale lowered the following year’s target 36 percent of the time in the comparisons researchers tracked.
  • Officials cut a roadside satisfaction target from 70 to 68 percent after a survey returned 68 percent.
In the article

“There's not anything subversive going on, these [changes] just reflect a shift in priorities.”

An unnamed city employee interviewed by Joyce Kasing Tagal and colleagues, Public Administration Review, 202603
Elsewhere3
Melbourne, Australia2012–2014

Melbourne added three to four minutes to Frankston train journeys in 2012. In 2014 the government claimed improved punctuality; a transport blogger found trains sitting at stations waiting for their timetable to catch up.

Daniel Bowen, transport blogger, November 201412
China2023

Chinese officials stopped publishing youth unemployment after it reached 21.3% in June 2023. Six months later they resumed with students excluded from the count; the new rate was 14.9%.

Harold Thibault, Le Monde correspondent, September 202611
United States2020

Norwegian Cruise Line, a cruise operator, replaced a profit target with a cost target during the pandemic. Its board then excluded expenses including spoiled supplies. The chief executive received a $3.6 million incentive bonus during a $4 billion annual loss.

Bloomberg Tax, April 202213
Sources13 works and reports · 13 outbound linksopen
  1. Source1

    学生“慢科研”联合倡议——致所有有志于科研的本科生们

    2026-10-17

    Read original source
  2. Source2

    Dari Pendamping Pasien hingga Joki ”Check Out” Belanja Daring

    Caecilia Mediana, Fidelia Fortunaya Hardjosukanto · 2026-10-18

    Read original source
  3. Source3

    The Practice and Origins of Performance Measurement: Assessing the Sunnyvale Model, 1984–2023

    Joyce Kasing Tagal, Derek Ouyang, Daniel E. Ho · 2026-09-03

    Read original source
  4. Source4

    Der beste Käse der Welt

    Hans Gerlach

    Read original source
  5. Source5

    Class Dismissed

    Hannah Gais

    Read original source
  6. Source6

    Peter Higgs: I wouldn't be productive enough for today's academic system

    The Guardian

    Read original source
  7. Source7

    Stand-in Labor and the Rising Economy of Self

    Michel Anteby; Nicholas Occhiuto

    Read original source
  8. Source8

    The Perfect Score

    Alison Stewart

    Read original source
  9. Source9

    Personalities for Sale

    Current Affairs

    Read original source
  10. Source10

    On the Good which Abides: Moral Letter 27

    Seneca

    Read original source
  11. Source11

    « La Chine a un problème d’emploi, quoi qu’en disent ses statistiques »

    Harold Thibault

    Read original source
  12. Source12

    Yes, train punctuality has increased – thanks to timetable padding

    Daniel Bowen

    Read original source
  13. Source13

    How Companies Stack the Deck for CEO Bonuses, Even in Down Years

    Bloomberg Tax

    Read original source