The Punchline reads the press you don’t get to. Every day we go through thousands of newspapers, magazines and journals in more than 30 languages. Software does the first reading. Our editors keep what is worth repeating at dinner.

Tell us the occasion and we build you a brief for it. Or browse. Vignettes follow one development as it turns up in several countries at once. Question Marks take an idea most people accept and set out the case for and against. The Newsletter brings the day’s selection every evening, free of charge.

THE PUNCHLINE

Your guide to shining at dinner parties

Question Mark · 17

Does paying for results leave the hardest work undone?

Reading time · 3 min

Colombia's carbon-tax money may drift from its falling forest: companies could pay it all in forest credits, whose projects mostly sit outside the worst-cleared zones.

La Silla Vacía·COLOMBIA | 2026
  • In October 2026, Colombia's environment minister proposed scrapping its forest fund and letting companies pay all carbon tax through credits.
  • Up to half can already go that way, to projects claiming to keep forest standing.
  • The fund gets 80% of the tax and pays farming families where forest is being cleared.
  • Credit projects sit elsewhere: departments with 76% of the clearing hold just 12% of project area.
In the article

Nine of the 18 deforestation hotspots have no known REDD+ forest-credit project in their area.

Javier Sabogal Mogollón, environmental economist, La Silla Vacía, October 202601
Elsewhere3
Britain2008–2015

A British job adviser was told to label unemployed clients green, amber or red. Contractors earned job-start payments, and red clients facing several barriers were to receive little attention.

A former job adviser’s fieldwork, Social Policy & Administration, 201902
Countries supported by Gavi2014–2016

Gavi, the international vaccine alliance, paid governments for vaccination results. Its 2016 review found that rewards largely went to countries already above 90% third-dose coverage for a combined childhood vaccine.

Development economist Paul Clist, Payment by results in international development, 2018, citing Gavi’s board report03
Costa RicaProgram begun in 1997; evaluations 2007–2013

Costa Rica paid landowners to protect forest that was unlikely to be cleared anyway. Early evaluations found little effect on deforestation.

Environmental researchers led by Jan Börner, The Effectiveness of Payments for Environmental Services, 201704
And it's not just them·2 more
NETHERLANDS | 2026

1Can a checklist decide which art deserves funding?

  • Since July 1, 2026, the Netherlands Film Fund gives five points to scripts that pass the Bechdel test.
  • Its production incentive, a main source of money for Dutch films and series, requires 75 points, and top scorers go first when money runs short.
  • A script passes when two named women talk about something other than a man; diversity points used to require a main cast reflecting society.
  • A film rights lawyer warns that cutting that conversation in the edit can cost filmmakers the subsidy.
In the article

“The sexist comedy American Pie 2 passes because two women briefly talk about clothes.”

De seksistische komedie American Pie 2 slaagt omdat twee vrouwen het even over kleren hebben.

Floortje Smit, film critic, de Volkskrant, October 202605
Elsewhere3
Canada2020–2022

A documentary called Gotta Love Trump qualified for Canada’s production tax-credit program, which scores Canadian staffing. A Toronto Maple Leafs series narrated by Canadian actor Will Arnett failed to qualify.

Michael Geist, University of Ottawa law professor, March 16, 202208
Hamburg and Schleswig-Holstein2024

A German film fund makes applicants complete checklists of minorities represented in their films. One filmmaker complained, “Everyone does the same thing to get financial support.”

Alle machen das Gleiche, um finanzielle Unterstützung zu bekommen.

Narges Kahlor, filmmaker, quoted in Berliner Zeitung, October 21, 202407
Britain2015–2019

Grand Theft Auto V passed Britain’s cultural test despite its fictional California setting. Rockstar North, its developer, received £42 million in tax credits under a program requiring 16 of 31 cultural points.

The Guardian, July 29, 201906
BRAZIL | 2026

2Can you trust advice from someone who profits when you lose?

  • In August 2026, Brazil's President Lula vowed to end betting companies; on September 25 he was due to announce curbs.
  • Betting companies paid social-media influencers fortunes to steer their followers onto gambling websites.
  • Influencer Virgínia Fonseca's 2022 contract paid her 30 reais of every 100 her referred followers lost.
  • After an influencer's course on winning at Aviator, a betting game, real-estate agent Tathiara Barbosa Fonseca lost 1.88 million reais in three years.
In the article

Fonseca received a 50-million-real advance when she signed the betting contract in 2022.

Piauí, Brazilian magazine, September 202609
Elsewhere3
United States1956

Lawyer Roy Cohn tipped Senator Joseph McCarthy to buy a uranium stock, then advertised McCarthy’s investment around Wall Street. Cohn sold for a $500,000 profit without telling him. McCarthy lost his investment.

Biographers Kai Bird and Susan Goldmark, discussing American Scoundrel at CUNY, October 202610
New York2014

On New Year’s Eve, a collector learned that his $118 million Modigliani had sold for $93.5 million. He said he had hired a broker for 2%; the intermediary said he was a seller.

Journalist Agustino Fontevecchia, Forbes, March 201511
Pittsburgh2000s

Researchers paid student advisers more when other students overvalued jars of coins. The guessers earned money for accuracy. After disclosure, advisers exaggerated more and the guesses became less accurate.

Daylian Cain, behavioral researcher, The Dirt on Coming Clean, undated doctoral dissertation12
Sources12 works and reports · 12 outbound linksopen
  1. Source1

    Enterrar el Fondo para la Vida aleja la plata del bosque amenazado

    Javier Sabogal Mogollón

    Read original source
  2. Source2

    Intensity, Moderation, and the Pressures of Expectation: Calculation and Coercion in the Street-Level Practice of Welfare Conditionality

    2019

    Read original source
  3. Source3

    Payment by results in international development: Evidence from the first decade

    Paul Clist, 2018

    Read original source
  4. Source4

    The Effectiveness of Payments for Environmental Services

    Jan Börner and colleagues, 2017

    Read original source
  5. Source5

    Zakt je film voor de weinigzeggende Bechdeltest? Dan kan dat nu financiële consequenties hebben

    Floortje Smit

    Read original source
  6. Source6

    Grand Theft Auto maker has paid no UK corporation tax in 10 years

    Read original source
  7. Source7

    Subventionierte Konformität: Wie staatliche Förderung kritische Kunst erstickt

    Peter Truschner

    Read original source
  8. Source8

    Bill C-11’s Foundational Faults, Part Five: How is Gotta Love Trump Cancon but Amazon’s Toronto Maple Leafs Series Isn’t?

    Michael Geist

    Read original source
  9. Source9

    COMO O BRASIL FOI ENGOLIDO PELAS BETS

    Read original source
  10. Source10

    American Scoundrel: Roy Cohn Biography - Kai Bird, Susan Goldmark, and Ken Auletta

    Biographers Kai Bird and Susan Goldmark, discussing American Scoundrel at CUNY, October 2026

    Read original source
  11. Source11

    Steve Cohen’s Modigliani in the Middle of an Art Market War

    Journalist Agustino Fontevecchia, Forbes, March 2015

    Read original source
  12. Source12

    The Dirt on Coming Clean: The Perverse Effects of Disclosing Conflicts of Interest

    Behavioral researcher Daylian Cain, The Dirt on Coming Clean, doctoral dissertation, chapter II

    Read original source