The Punchline reads the press you don’t get to. Every day we go through thousands of newspapers, magazines and journals in more than 30 languages. Software does the first reading. Our editors keep what is worth repeating at dinner.

Tell us the occasion and we build you a brief for it. Or browse. Vignettes follow one development as it turns up in several countries at once. Question Marks take an idea most people accept and set out the case for and against. The Newsletter brings the day’s selection every evening, free of charge.

THE PUNCHLINE

Your guide to shining at dinner parties

Question Mark · 24

Does raising money from a harmful business make us protect it?

Reading time · 3 min

New Mexico funds free child care with oil money, De Haaland, running for governor after pledging to reject fossil-fuel donations, now calls the industry necessary.

Mother Jones·NEW MEXICO | 2026
  • Deb Haaland, former US interior secretary running for New Mexico governor in 2026, took oil money she'd pledged to refuse.
  • Oil-and-gas money funds nearly half New Mexico's budget, including free child care, college tuition and school meals.
  • Haaland now calls oil and gas a necessary evil as the state trails its 2030 emissions targets.
  • State fund managers expect earnings on saved windfalls to overtake oil-and-gas revenue by 2042.
In the article

Nearly half of New Mexico’s $10.2 billion operating budget came from oil-and-gas windfalls in 2025.

Jenni Monet, reporting in Mother Jones, October 202601
Elsewhere3
France1852–1870

Asked to ban tobacco, Emperor Napoleon III pointed to the 100 million francs it raised annually. He promised to forbid it as soon as someone named a virtue that brought in as much money.

K. Ashok Vardhan Shetty, retired Indian civil servant, The Hindu, September 26, 202604
Chicago1880s

Temperance leader Frances Willard opposed raising Chicago’s saloon fees in 1886. To her, liquor revenue was a pact with the devil that gave the trade the state’s stamp; saloon fees already supplied 40 percent of Chicago’s annual budget.

Richard R. John, historian, “Home Protection: Frances Willard’s Anti-Monopoly Crusade,” 202605
United StatesAfter 1892

Steel magnate Andrew Carnegie hoped his library gifts would reconcile workers with rich employers. Some communities refused them because he had crushed the Homestead strike.

Historian Kim Phillips-Fein and the hosts of Know Your Enemy, August 24, 202606
And it's not just them·2 more
DUTCH REPUBLIC | 16th–17th centuries

1Does a state protect the industries that pay its bills?

  • The Netherlands, the rebelling provinces, decades before 1648. Rebels fighting Spain for independence funded their war with a beer tax.
  • The States General, the rebel government, seized the town councils' tax on every barrel of beer sold.
  • Taxing brewers scattered in every hamlet was cumbersome, so the rebels outlawed home brewing, then brewing outside major towns.
In the article

“The average European drank one to two liters of beer a day before the Dutch revolt.”

Peer Schouten, describing Dutch wartime brewing controls in The Baffler, October 202602
Elsewhere3
Vietnam1952

Vietnam’s revolutionary government made state shops the only lawful buyers of opium in 1952. Guerrillas used it as currency behind French lines, and the agriculture minister wanted production maintained for the treasury.

Christian C. Lentz, geographer, Cultivating Subjects: Opium and Rule in Post-colonial Vietnam, Modern Asian Studies, 2017.11
Russia16th–18th centuries

Russian rulers opened state taverns where food was forbidden. Vodka revenue helped Catherine the Great defeat the Ottoman Empire and establish colonies on the Black Sea.

Sonja Margolina, author of Vodka: Drinking and Power in Russia, Neue Zürcher Zeitung, November 2024.10
Japan1904

Japan’s finance ministry took over cigarette manufacturing in 1904, citing the need to preserve wartime tax revenue. It expanded its tobacco-leaf monopoly to shut out the American Tobacco Company.

Mark Levin, law professor, Tobacco Industrial Policy and Tobacco Control Policy in Japan, 2005.12
ENGLAND | 2026

2Can money be separated from the harm that made it?

  • In 2026, critics' media campaign and a legal challenge have stalled the Church of England's proposed £100 million fund addressing its slavery links.
  • The church's £11.6 billion endowment partly descends from Queen Anne's Bounty, a fund that invested in the slave-trading South Sea Company.
  • The Church Commissioners, who manage the endowment, plan to invest the money and use returns to support communities affected by African enslavement.
  • Opponents want the money spent on struggling parishes; the church says the fund will not divert money from parishes.
In the article

“Addressing our historic links to African chattel enslavement is an act of Christian repentance, responsible investment and credible witness.”

John Collingridge, reporting on the Merlin Strategy poll in The Guardian, October 202603
Elsewhere3
Barbados2023

A British lawmaker still owned his family’s former slave plantation in Barbados in 2023. The island’s poet laureate wanted it turned into a museum and agricultural school.

TIME’s report on lawmaker Richard Drax and poet laureate Esther Phillips, July 202309
Germany2019

A family holding a stake in sandwich chain Pret A Manger pledged €10 million after investigating its ancestors’ use of Nazi forced labor. Its fortune was estimated at €33 billion.

BBC News, March 201907
Britain / Grenada1833 / 2023

A British family received £34,000 when slavery ended, as compensation for losing enslaved people. In 2023, its descendants apologized and pledged £100,000 to a community fund in Grenada.

The Guardian’s account of the Trevelyan family’s pledge, March 202308
Sources12 works and reports · 12 outbound linksopen
  1. Source1

    Deb Haaland Is Racing Against Her Own Record

    Jenni Monet · 2026-10-31

    Read original source
  2. Source2

    The Beer Wars

    Peer Schouten · 2026-10-26

    Read original source
  3. Source3

    Battle over the C of E’s slavery fund

    John Collingridge · 2026-10-14

    Read original source
  4. Source4

    The case for accountable lottery regulation in India

    K. Ashok Vardhan Shetty, 2026-09-26

    Read original source
  5. Source5

    Home Protection: Frances Willard’s Anti-Monopoly Crusade

    Richard R. John, 2026-09-28

    Read original source
  6. Source6

    The Long Struggle Against Equality in America (w/ Kim Phillips-Fein)

    Kim Phillips-Fein, 2026-08-24

    Read original source
  7. Source7

    Reimann family firm reveals Nazi slave past in Germany

    BBC News, March 25, 2019

    Read original source
  8. Source8

    More than Money: The Logic of Slavery Reparations

    The Guardian, March 2023

    Read original source
  9. Source9

    Inside Barbados’ Historic Push for Slavery Reparations

    TIME, July 3, 2023

    Read original source
  10. Source10

    Russlands Trunksucht

    Sonja Margolina · 2024-11-27

    Read original source
  11. Source11

    Cultivating Subjects: Opium and rule in post-colonial Vietnam

    Christian C. Lentz · 2017

    Read original source
  12. Source12

    Tobacco Industrial Policy and Tobacco Control Policy in Japan

    Mark Levin · 2005

    Read original source