The Punchline reads the press you don’t get to. Every day we go through thousands of newspapers, magazines and journals in more than 30 languages. Software does the first reading. Our editors keep what is worth repeating at dinner.

Tell us the occasion and we build you a brief for it. Or browse. Vignettes follow one development as it turns up in several countries at once. Question Marks take an idea most people accept and set out the case for and against. The Newsletter brings the day’s selection every evening, free of charge.

THE PUNCHLINE

Your guide to shining at dinner parties

Question Mark · 18

Can you trust work no one can explain?

Reading time · 3 min

Mathematics professors want doctoral candidates to defend their theses in person, because AI can produce convincing work the candidate does not understand.

Il Mulino·UNITED STATES | 2026
  • In mid-September 2026, 24 mathematics professors from Harvard, MIT, Stanford, Princeton, Berkeley and elsewhere met to rethink the doctorate.
  • Universities grade students on written work, but AI now produces convincing work for students who understood nothing.
  • The professors proposed awarding doctorates mainly on a discussion demanding complete command of the thesis, not on its text.
  • They also recommended in-person checks before several professors at least once a year.
In the article

“One consequence receives little attention, and perhaps explains the resistance: the oral examination also measures the examiner.”

Resta una conseguenza di cui si parla poco, e che spiega forse le resistenze: l’orale misura anche l’esaminatore.

Pierluigi Contucci, mathematician, Il Mulino, October 202601
Elsewhere3
InternationalAugust 2026

A machine-learning journal invited ten author teams to discuss papers already headed for rejection. Three withdrew or did not attend, three could not answer basic questions, and three managed only an outline. The remaining team answered and was invited to revise its paper.

Nikolaj Thams, statistics researcher, Weekendavisen, September 202604
Paris1903

The Louvre, the Paris art museum, bought a supposedly ancient gold tiara in 1896. French officials later summoned its living maker to demonstrate his authorship. He made a miniature copy now held by the British Museum.

British Museum, collection record for a miniature by goldsmith Israel Rouchomovsky05
Los AngelesNovember 1990

The pop duo Milli Vanilli lost their Grammy after admitting that other performers sang their album. At a Hollywood press conference, they sang without accompaniment to prove they could sing. More than 200 reporters and photographers were there.

United Press International reporting on the duo’s press conference, November 21, 199006
And it's not just them·2 more
TURIN, ITALY | 1960s

1Does keeping quiet make you less trustworthy?

  • In 1960s Turin, a doctor at Fiat, the carmaker, asked workers how they actually did their jobs.
  • Workers repeated company instructions and withheld the unofficial tricks they used to get through a shift.
  • The doctor asked each worker to train an imaginary replacement so well that nobody would notice the substitution.
  • Workers then described timings and unwritten rules that appeared in no handbook.
In the article

Nine doctors working with the Fiat doctor later reported as many occupational illnesses as all other doctors in the region combined

Evgeny Morozov, writer, Flamman, September 202602
Elsewhere3
Online programming forums2017

A programmer said he had automated his full-time job and kept the scripts secret because he feared dismissal once his employer had them. He deliberately inserted occasional bugs to make the work look human.

Business Insider report republished by ScienceAlert, July 201707
Place unspecified1946

Factory crews refused to teach newcomers the unofficial tricks needed to earn the day rate unless they agreed to limit output. Persistent holdouts could be forced out of the job.

Arthur McLuhan, sociologist, “Adopting a Cloak of Incompetence,” 2020, citing Collins, Dalton and Roy’s factory study08
New York2026

New Yorkers can hire cleaners for free. Recordings of the cleaning are sold to Shift, a company collecting examples of manual work to train robots.

Wojtek Żubr Boliński, writer, Krytyka Polityczna, September 202609
UNITED STATES | 2004; discussed in 2026

2Would you trust a treatment if the theory behind it is wrong?

  • Cognitive behavioural therapy dominates psychotherapy because it wins trials, which score whether patients improve, not whether theory holds.
  • Psychologist Steven C. Hayes says those wins cannot prove its explanation is right.
  • His example: 18th-century theorists boiled kettles using a theory of fire built on phlogiston, a substance that never existed.
In the article

More than 1,000 randomized controlled trials had evaluated acceptance and commitment therapy, a treatment using mindfulness, by 2024.

Steven C. Hayes and G. A. King, psychotherapy researchers, cited by Jonas Ringström, 202603
Elsewhere3
Europe1850 onward

A chemist and a celebrated chef taught cooks to sear meat to seal in its juices. Water escapes through the crust, but the browning adds flavour.

Exploratorium science museum, explaining the claims of chemist Justus von Liebig and chef Auguste Escoffier in “Searing Steak”10
English Channel1747–1772

A naval surgeon reported in 1747 that oranges and lemons improved scurvy faster than five rival treatments. He explained scurvy through faulty digestion and excretion, and remained reluctant to recommend a remedy whose action he could not explain.

I. Milne, historian of medicine, Who was James Lind, and what exactly did he achieve?, James Lind Library, 2012.12
Netherlands and United States2011

Engineers built a riderless bicycle that cancelled its wheels’ gyroscopic effect and reversed the usual front-wheel geometry. When pushed sideways as it rolled, it righted itself without either effect thought necessary for balance.

J. D. G. Kooijman and colleagues, engineers, A Bicycle Can Be Self-Stable Without Gyroscopic or Caster Effects, Science, 2011.11
Sources12 works and reports · 12 outbound linksopen
  1. Source1

    La viva voce, un futuro che avevamo già

    Pierluigi Contucci · 2026-10-22

    Read original source
  2. Source2

    Så kan AI bli en kraft för frigörelse

    Jevgenij Morozov · 2026-09-17

    Read original source
  3. Source3

    ‘A Science More Adequate to the Challenge of the Human Condition’: Boundary Work in Psychotherapy Research

    Jonas Ringström · 2026-10-22

    Read original source
  4. Source4

    Autogenereret overflod

    Nikolaj Thams, 2026-09-29

    Read original source
  5. Source5

    Tiara; case (1986,1021.1.a–b)

    British Museum

    Read original source
  6. Source6

    Milli Vanilli members say they were seduced by fame

    United Press International

    Read original source
  7. Source7

    Programmers Are Secretly Automating Their Jobs And Only Working a Few Hours a Week

    Business Insider, republished by ScienceAlert

    Read original source
  8. Source8

    Adopting a Cloak of Incompetence: Impression Management Techniques for Feigning Lesser Selves

    Arthur McLuhan

    Read original source
  9. Source9

    Panoptikon, na którym możesz zarabiać już teraz

    Wojtek Żubr Boliński

    Read original source
  10. Source10

    Searing Steak

    Exploratorium

    Read original source
  11. Source11

    A Bicycle Can Be Self-Stable Without Gyroscopic or Caster Effects

    J. D. G. Kooijman, J. P. Meijaard, Jim M. Papadopoulos, Andy Ruina and A. L. Schwab

    Read original source
  12. Source12

    Who was James Lind, and what exactly did he achieve?

    I. Milne

    Read original source